Pies & So Much More!
All of these wonderful goodies are made from scratch daily using the finest ingredients at each of our locations!
Cherry
Featuring Northern Michigan Montmorency Tart Cherries
Old Mission Cherry
Grand Traverse Cherry Crumb
Cherry Peach Crumb
Long Lake Berry Cherry (raspberries & cherries)
Orchard Natural Cherry (no sugar added)
Splenda™ Cherry |
Apple
Made with Northern Michigan Spy Apples... the undisputed "best"!
Front Street Apple
Peninsula Apple Crumb
Gill's Pier Apple Dumpling (7 whole apples)
Apple Dumpling w/Caramel Topping
East Bay Natural Apple |
Blueberry
Berries from Northern Michigan... Naturally sweet globes of goodness!
Suttons Bay Blueberry
Opera House Blueberry Peach
West Bay Blueberry Crumb |
Blackberry
A distinct, moderately tart, delicious flavor!
Riverside Blackberry
Tall Ship Blackberry Peach Crumb |
Lemon Meringue
The classic that Grandma was famous for! |
Peach
Savor this golden, rosy-blushed sweet and nutritious fruit in your pie!
Farmer's Market Peach
Glen Haven Peach Crumb
Union Street Peach Strawberry |
Berry
Only the freshest berries to flavor your pie!
Lakeshore Berry*
Lakeshore Berry Crumb*
(*strawberry, raspberry, blackberry & apple)
Firehouse Strawberry Rhubarb
Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb
Holiday Hill Rhubarb
Good Harbor Raspberry
Leelanau Raspberry Apple Crumb |
Seasonal
Using only choice ingredients from the harvest!
Autumn Harvest Pecan
Blissful Pecan Chocolate Chip
Northport Pumpkin
Genevieve's Pumpkin with Pecans |
Cream Pies
Coconut
Banana
Chocolate
Peanut Butter
Mocha
Butterscotch |
Key Lime
A taste of the Tropics! |
Cookies
Delicious, old-fashioned hand-made treats!
Chocolate Chunk
Cherry Oatmeal
Sugar Cookie
Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip |
Turnovers
A little piece of heaven wrapped in our golden, flaky pie crust
Apple
Peach
Blueberry
Bavarian Creme
Cherry |
Cakes
Our baking expertise focused on cakes!
Carrot Cake
Death by Chocolate |
Cheesecakes
A deliciously rich and creamy addition to our menu... like no other cheesecakes!
Plain
Oreo
Turtle
Pumpkin
Baley's
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Peppermint
Cherry Crumb
Cherry Peach Crumb
Lakeshore Berry
Fruit Swirl |
Muffins
Cherry Pecan
Blueberry
Raspberry
Double Chocolate
Lemon Poppyseed
Pumpkin
Pumpkin w/Pecans
and more! |
Dessert Bars
Sweet treats that are an easy snack on the go!
Goodie Bars
Lemon Bars
Chocolate Peanut-Butter Bars
Pumpkin Bars
Turtle Delights
Rise Krispy Treats
Frosted Brownies |
Mini Pies
A 6" version of our famous pies!
Apple Crumb
Cherry Crumb
Blueberry Crumb
Peach Crumb
Pecan
Chocolate Cream
Coconut Cream
Banana Cream |
